Statistical Physics Can Help Uncover the Impact of Media on Decision Making
Students and researchers from HSE University and the Landau Institute for Theoretical Physics have examined the widely known ‘Prisoner’s Dilemma’ game using methods from statistical physics. They used the mean-field concept, a common tool for studying the physics of many-particle systems, to describe human decision-making processes. Researchers suggest that this model may be helpful for understanding systems with many participants. The results of the study are published in the September issue of the Physics Review Research journal.
The paper’s authors looked at the spatial variation of the ‘Prisoner’s Dilemma’ game—the Nowak-May game—from a new perspective. In particular, they included statistical physics methods in the game’s rules. ‘In the classic version of the dilemma, there are two “players.” We used a modified version with a large number of agents,’ said Lev Shchur, Professor, Department Head and Chief Research Fellow at MIEM HSE.
The game is played with participants’ ‘nearest neighbours’, just like communicating with family and co-workers in real life. The players’ individual opinions sum up to a kind of average opinion, which in the suggested model directly impacts the decisions made by the players. Then an individual’s behaviour is determined by this ‘mean-field,’ formed by the behaviour of all individuals in the population. This construction is successfully used in statistical physics, which studies the emergent behaviour of large numbers of interacting particles.
The main feature of the model is that it considers both the structure of the population and the mean-field impact. The authors believe that the model might play a key role in the study of social systems. For example, in the paper, the presence of a mean-field is interpreted as the media’s impact on personal decisions, something that previous models of this kind haven’t considered.
It has been established that the spatial version of the Prisoner’s Dilemma game features sharp transitions between different steady states. The authors find that the new approach allows for a smoothening of these transitions. This is the first indication of the co-existence of two types of transitions—sharp and smooth—in deterministic systems.
The scholars believe that this model may help understand how systems with large numbers of participants behave or how the media impacts individual choices.
Evgeni Burovski, Associate Professor at the HSE School of Applied Mathematics
We have obtained some exciting results. In classical evolutionary game models, Darwinian processes are described in terms of well-mixed populations, and the information on the structure of the population is lost. We are suggesting an alternative approach — games both with a local neighbourhood and the self-consistent mean-field opinion. This approach helps consider the impact on decision making that the closest environment (colleagues and friends) has, as well as the things that people hear or read in the news.
The suggested approach can be applied to a broad class of spatial evolutionary games with both deterministic and stochastic rules. Given the interdisciplinary nature of the study, the researchers hope to collaborate with their colleagues working in sociology and economics to further develop and apply the model in trials.
Evgeny Burovskiy
Associate Professor, School of Applied Mathematics
Lev Shchur
Chief Research Fellow, Laboratory of the Internet of Things and Cyber-physical Systems
See also:
HSE Scientists Have Developed a New Model of Electric Double Layer
This new model accounts for a wide range of ion-electrode interactions and predicts a device's ability to store electric charge. The model's theoretical predictions align with the experimental results. Data on the behaviour of the electric double layer (EDL) can aid in the development of more efficient supercapacitors for portable electronics and electric vehicles. The study has been published in ChemPhysChem.
HSE Scientist Optimises Solution of Hydrodynamics Problems
Roman Gaydukov, Associate Professor at the MIEM HSE School of Applied Mathematics, has modelled the fluid flow around a rotating disk with small surface irregularities. His solution allows for predicting fluid flow behaviour without the need for powerful supercomputers. The results have been published in Russian Journal of Mathematical Physics.
Physicists from Russia and Brazil Unveil Mystery behind Complex Superconductor Patterns
Scientists at HSE MIEM and MIPT have demonstrated that highly complex spatial structures, similar to the intricate patterns found in nature, can emerge in superconductors. Mathematically, these patterns are described using the Ginzburg–Landau equation at a specific combination of parameters known as the Bogomolny point. The paper has been published in the Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter.
Adhesive Tape Helps Create Innovative THz Photodetector
An international team of researchers, including scientists at HSE University and Moscow Pedagogical State University (MPGU), has developed a novel photodetector composed of a thin superconducting film, capable of detecting weak terahertz (THz) radiation. This discovery holds promise for studying objects in space, developing wireless broadband communication systems, and making advancements in spectroscopy. The study has been published in Nano Letters.
Operation of Cellular Networks Found Similar to Bacteria Growth in Petri Dish
Scientists at the HSE Laboratory for Computational Physics have developed a new model for analysing communication networks that can significantly enhance the speed of mobile communications. To achieve this, the researchers used computational physics methods and phase transition models. It turns out that the functioning of cellular networks is in many ways similar to the growth of surfaces in physics. The study was performed using the HPC cHARISMa cluster at HSE University. The study findings have been published in Frontiers in Physics.
The Saudi Arabian National Team, Medal Winners at the International Physics Olympiad, Trained at HSE University
At the recent International Physics Olympiad (IPhO 2024) in Iran, students from Saudi Arabia achieved the best results in their country's history, winning one silver and three bronze medals. The team from the Kingdom made their first visit to Russia to receive their final training at the HSE Faculty of Physics.
'I've Always Been Keen to Engage in Experiments and Operate Scientific Instruments'
During his early years at university, physicist Ivan Makhov worried that he might be dismissed, but today he is heading a study supported by a grant from the Russian Science Foundation. In this interview with the HSE Young Scientists project, he shares his work experience using a closed-loop cryostat, his dream of conversing with Einstein, and favourite location in his hometown of St Petersburg.
‘Two Interdisciplinary Research Centres Can Create New Synergy between Themselves’
In mid-June 2024, HSE University and the Joint Institute for Nuclear Research in Dubna held a joint working meeting. This meeting was the first under an agreement signed by the research centres in 2024, when HSE University and JINR agreed to jointly participate in experiments of the NICA megascience project, as well as interact in the field of theoretical and mathematical physics, information technology, and personnel training. These issues were the focus of the first working meeting. Details are in the JINR report.
‘I Aspire to Make a Contribution Comparable to Prometheus' Gift to Humanity'
Egor Sedov initially planned to pursue a career in programming but instead became captivated by experimental physics. In this interview with the HSE Young Scientists project, he spoke about the quantum effect and the quantum standard, a scientist's letter from the future, and the magnetic levitation of a frog.
Russian Scientists Pioneer Accurate Mathematical Description of Quantum Dicke Battery
Physicists at HSE University and NUST MISIS have formulated and solved equations for a quantum battery, a device capable of storing energy in the form of light. Their findings will facilitate precise calculations of the capacity, power, and duration required for optimal battery charging. Quantum batteries are expected to improve the performance of solar panels and electric vehicles, while also opening up new avenues for efficient energy transfer. The study has been published in Physical Review A.